Bronze trophies
Cruz 'in the Field - Catch a 90+ yard TD pass with Victor Cruz.
Jahvid Best Award - Score on an 88+ yard TD run.
Honing Your Skills - Complete a practice in Superstar Mode.
Demaryius Thomas Award - Catch a game winning TD pass in OT.
Tim Tebow Award - Rush for 118+ yards with your QB.
Safety Inspector Award - Tackle the ball carrier in their own end zone.
Happy 21st EA SPORTS! - Score 21 points in a game.
Arian Foster Award - Rush for 168+ yards with a single player in a game.
Tom Brady Award - Have a total offense of 519+ yards in a game.
Cam Newton Award - Score 3 rushing TDs with a QB in a game.
Houston Texans Award - Gain over 100+ yards rushing with 2 HBs in the same game.
Chopping Block - Complete one season's final cut day in Franchise Mode.
Tactical Masher - Win a player in FA bidding in Franchise Mode.
Future Hall of Famer? - Create an NFL Superstar.

Silver trophies
Devin Hester Award - Score a TD on a Kick Return.
Wes Welker Award - Catch 16+ passes in one game with one player.
Matthew Stafford Award - Pass for 520+ yards in one game with one player.
DeMarco Murray Award - Rush for 253+ yards in a game with one player.
Sebastian Janikowski Award - Kick a 60+ yard FG.
Drew Brees Award - Complete 88% of your passes (minimum 20 attempts).
Calvin Johnson Award - Gain 244+ yards receiving with one player.
Cleveland Browns Award - Hold your opponent to 137 or fewer yards of total offense.
Buffalo Bills Award - Record 10+ sacks as a team in one game.
Maurice Jones-Drew Award - Score 4+ rushing TDs in a single game with 1 player.

Gold trophies
Ted Ginn Jr. Award - Score 2+ Kick Return TDs in a single game.
Verizon Scoreboard Overload - Score 50 points in one game.
Patrick Peterson Award - Return a punt for a TD in OT.
Darrelle Revis Award - Return an interception for 100+ yards.
Vince Wilfork Award - Score a fumble recovery TD with a Defensive Linemen.

Platinum trophy
Madden NFL 13 Master - Earn all Bronze, Silver, and Gold trophies.