Bronze trophies
'RESPECT THE GAME!' - In any game mode, enter a game with a mismatching uniform.
Back, Back, Back, Back, Back... - Hit a home run of 490ft or more in Home Run Derby.
Cruzball - Playing as the pitcher in any game mode, intentionally walk a batter, then turn a double play. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Deep Dish - Hit a home run into the Bullpen Sports Grill in rightfield at U.S. Cellular Field. (CWS)
Don't Try That Again - On defense, throw a runner out at 3B or home plate from the outfield. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Fish off a Barrel - Hit the aquarium behind home plate at Marlins Park. (MIA)
Go Chasin' Waterfalls - Hit a home run into a waterfall at Kauffman Stadium. (KC)
In The Bag! - As the batter, hit 1st, 2nd, or 3rd base with the ball. Trophy is not achievable in Home Run Derby.
Loud and Clear - Hit a home run into the speaker in center field at Dodger Stadium. (LAD)
On The Beach - Hit a home run into the sand area in Petco Park. (SD)
Plowman - As a baserunner, plow the catcher. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Pulsating - With the pitching difficulty set to All-Star or higher, use Pulse Pitching to strike out the side. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Run Benjie, Run! - Steal a base with a player whose primary position is Catcher. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Sombrero Dealer - In any mode, strike out the same player four times in a game. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Squeezeball - In any game mode, win the game with an RBI bunt. Must be done in a full, uninterrupted, 9 inning game against the CPU controlled team.
Take Out Your Rival - In any mode, hit the opposing pitcher with a pitch.
Texas Two-Step - Hit a home run onto Greene's Hill in CF at Rangers Ballpark In Arlington. (TEX)
The Old Fashioned Way - In any mode,earn save by having your reliever pitch last 3 innings of a win.Must be done in full,uninterrupted,9 inning game against CPU controlled
Vulture a Win - In any mode,blow save & get win w/ same pitcher Must be done in full,uninterrupted,9 inning game against the CPU controlled team.
You Blew It - In any mode, blow your opponents save opportunity. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Zone Plus Analog Blast - W/ hitting difficulty set to All-Star or harder,hit home run using Zone Plus Analog controls.This trophy isn't unlockable in Home Run Derby modes.

Silver trophies
Contact Killer - In any mode,excluding RttS,play an entire 9 inning game w/o striking out.Must be done in full,uninterrupted,9 inning game against CPU controlled team.
Don't Phase Me Bro - In any game mode, hit a home run off a 100+ MPH pitch. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Early Exit - In any game mode, knock out the opponent's starting pitcher before the end of the 3rd inning. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
For the Greater Good - In any game mode, get a broken bat base hit.
Meatbull Buffet - Bat around in inning.Must be completed on All-Star or higher Batting difficulty.Must be done in full,uninterrupted,9 inning game against CPU control
Mr. 300 - Reach 300 XP in online play.
Quality Start - Throw > 70% 1st pitch strikes in complete game victory.Must be done in full, uninterrupted, 9 inning game against CPU controlled team.
Rally Killer - In any game mode, hit into 2 double plays in a game with the same player. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Solid D - Using Pure Analog Throwing,w/throwing difficulty to All-Star or higher,complete 9 inning game w/o error.Must be done against CPU controlled team.

Gold trophies
King Slayer - In Exhib Mode,beat team ranked 1st overall in team select screen w/Pitching&Batting difficulties to Legend.Must be done in full,uninterrupted,9 inning
Million Dollar Man - In any game mode, throw a perfect game against a CPU controlled team. Must be done in a full, uninterrupted, 9 inning game.
Sooo Close! - Lose your shot at a perfect game or no hitter in the 9th inning. Must be done against a CPU controlled team.
Winning - Hit 10 consecutive home runs in Home Run Derby(TM).
You're the Man! - Reach 500 XP in online play.

Platinum trophy
Congratulations - Earn all Bronze, Silver, and Gold trophies.